Advertisement

When Intent Fails

Share:

From our common law beginnings, the intent of our legal system has always been to find the balance in protecting the rights of individuals with those of the larger community. Simply put: you steal my goat, you pay me or replace my goat.

While crude in many respects, this system brought order, decency, and accountability to the masses. But its simplicity is both a pro and a con. For one thing, it has required us to create additional legislation to clarify unique situations, and this has altered the fundamental balance of our rights. Finding this balance is often at the root of our disagreements over political philosophy—and rightly so, given life’s many complexities.

Many of these legislative adjustments have no doubt been required. But bureaucracy is often the bastard child of well-intentioned charity, and supporting that child is a challenge faced by the government and taxpayers alike as they get entangled in asinine legal webs.

Take rental properties, for example. While common law still reigns in commercial matters, when it comes to rental properties we have the Residential Tenancies Act. I lament this legislation to some extent, but it’s the lack of funding to properly administer it that’s the root of problems faced by both tenants and landlords. I wouldn’t suggest completely reversing it and going back to common law, but the complex webs that have been created in the name of equity and protecting all parties, coupled with overworked civil servants, has led to a system that borders on idiocy and ultimately hurts the people it was intended to serve. 

Under common law, if the rent goes unpaid, the landlord can take possession and seize the tenant’s assets. This works well in commercial contracts with savvy parties on both sides, but I would rue the day that a tenant arrives home to find the locks changed and their belongings left on the curb due to a small financial hardship or payment irregularity.

But under the existing system, a tenant who is causing issues, including lack of payment, can continue to live on the premises for months before the landlord can evict them. While the legal process is partially at fault, the judicial system is overburdened; if you were to apply for a hearing today, you might only get a hearing months from now. Little can be accomplished until such a hearing, so an educated tenant can live rent- and fancy-free for months. Add appeals and other delays and it’s possible for a tenant to retain residence for a considerable period of time without pay-ment. For landlords to get paid back rent, they must serve tenants in person—or indeed, tenants may never be found. And for tenants, the nuances of the complex system mean that well-educated landlords can exploit technicalities to their benefit.

Similar dysfunctions plague all aspects of our justice system. Many have fought traffic tickets only to win on appeal because the police officer wasn’t able to attend due to more pressing priorities. And if you plead guilty with an explanation, the justice in front of you will likely cut the fine to remove another file from their overly busy docket.

We need to ask ourselves a simple question: is this a just system?

Can we blame administrators and civil servants? I would think not, since their too-heavy workloads are often the root of the issue. We must instead look to legislators. Although we should commend their intent to create a just and functional society, perhaps they should ensure that the resources needed to administer laws, in terms of time and money, are already in place when those laws are enacted. Doing so would go a long way toward bringing some justice back into our system.

Or maybe, just maybe, we need to ask our political leaders to be more creative in passing legislation, perhaps legislation that can be enacted more cost-effectively, or perhaps even be self-administered.

Fairness is not created in the House of Commons or each province’s legislative assembly. It is created in the way we all choose to live, work, and do business in our collective society.

Simple, right?

Advertisement
More COMMENTARY

Chiseling Granite: The Value of a Flippant “I Love You”

Recently I’ve been thinking about love. Valentine’s Day has come and gone, but my mind is still stuck on love. The other day I walked into a building to attend a meeting and noticed another...

Read more

Recently I’ve been thinking about love. Valentine’s Day has come and gone, but my mind is still stuck on love. The other day I walked into a building to attend a meeting and noticed another...

Read more

The Mental Health Benefits of Eating Pizza

Well, Niverville, here we are. With half a dozen pizza places in town, it’s time to ask ourselves the hard questions. Questions like, “Where do you want to get pizza tonight?” and “Where do...

Read more

Well, Niverville, here we are. With half a dozen pizza places in town, it’s time to ask ourselves the hard questions. Questions like, “Where do you want to get pizza tonight?” and “Where do...

Read more
Advertisement

A Wartime Christmas

My dad, Arthur Wilson, was born on December 16, 1938 in Sarnia, Ontario. Dad grew up in wartime and poverty. His dad had signed up for the war in 1939, the day after England declared war on Germany,...

Read more

My dad, Arthur Wilson, was born on December 16, 1938 in Sarnia, Ontario. Dad grew up in wartime and poverty. His dad had signed up for the war in 1939, the day after England declared war on Germany,...

Read more

Blackout Fairy Tale

Growing up, my Christmases consisted of two traditions each Christmas Eve. First, after dinner we would go to church where us kids would perform a play for all the adults. Second, my family would...

Read more

Growing up, my Christmases consisted of two traditions each Christmas Eve. First, after dinner we would go to church where us kids would perform a play for all the adults. Second, my family would...

Read more
Advertisement

Navigating Disagreements During the Holidays

In last month’s mental health column, we learned about the psychological foundations of morality. Today we continue the topic, focusing on how to navigate moral disagreements and conflicts with...

Read more

In last month’s mental health column, we learned about the psychological foundations of morality. Today we continue the topic, focusing on how to navigate moral disagreements and conflicts with...

Read more

Right or Wrong? The Psychological Foundations of Morality

Think of someone you have a minor difference of opinion with. These disagreements might be a matter of personal preference, with no clear right or wrong answer. For example, what’s your favourite...

Read more

Think of someone you have a minor difference of opinion with. These disagreements might be a matter of personal preference, with no clear right or wrong answer. For example, what’s your favourite...

Read more
Advertisement

Gender Ideology vs. Gender Science: What the Brain Tells Us

Recently, there has been an increase in dialogue and protests in Canada on the subject of “gender ideology” in schools. The opposing sides fall into two camps: those who think that discussing...

Read more

Recently, there has been an increase in dialogue and protests in Canada on the subject of “gender ideology” in schools. The opposing sides fall into two camps: those who think that discussing...

Read more

Not in My Backyard? In Defence of Community Support for Mental Health

Recently, a resident of the RM of Richot made a request at a council meeting to host a home-based business at their property. This business would conduct workshops in a rural, natural environment...

Read more

Recently, a resident of the RM of Richot made a request at a council meeting to host a home-based business at their property. This business would conduct workshops in a rural, natural environment...

Read more
Time until next issue
Citizen Poll

Is it prudent for Niverville’s council to encourage a broad shift to municipal water as soon as the government grants become available?

For related article, see https://nivervillecitizen.com/...